Showing posts with label Batman: The Dark Knight Returns. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Batman: The Dark Knight Returns. Show all posts

Sunday, 17 November 2013

Batman: The Killing Joke


As its title indicates Batman: The Killing Joke is as much a Joker book as a Batman book. This may not seem particularly noteworthy now, when an entire month’s worth of DC comics can be dedicated to pushing villains to the fore and there are almost as many anti-heroes as there are straight villains. But in the late eighties the approach was still new enough to be a novelty. Even with a big name baddie like Joker. Which was almost certainly a factor when Alan Moore decided he wanted to write it.

The plot is fairly basic. Joker targets Commissioner Gordon with a series of vicious pranks and attacks, his goal bring to prove that anyone can be taken down to their lowest, insane ebb with one bad day. Batman saves the day (natch) by tussling with Joker and saving Gordon from his seemingly overwhelming despair. Along the way we get a look at The Joker before he became The Joker and Barbara ‘Batgirl’ Gordon gets shot.

I'm paraphrasing but that's the basic gist.

The shooting was a rare example of a comic book occurrence that had a long term impact. Barbara remained paralysed until DC’s line-wide reboot in 2011. It wasn’t something cynically dreamt up to create a readership spike, it was something Moore devised to have dramatic impact. It did and does.

As a Batman comic it works. It does something new with established characters without betraying their roots or emotions and captures the gritty feel of Gotham City. As an Alan Moore comic it also works. A bad guy dragging a morally courageous man down to his level just because he can is exactly the sort of thing Alan Moore is known for writing.  

The book is well-written and nicely paced over its dozens of pages. It's entertaining and benefits from some lovely art provided by Brian Bolland (with the deluxe edition currently on bookshelves getting a great recolour job also provided by Bolland). Perhaps most importantly it followed on from the themes that began with Frank Miller’s The Dark Knight Returns and played into the darkening of the Batman character. That's something we take for granted now as it's been the standard approach for twenty-five years, but it wasn't the guaranteed recipe for success when written that it is now. The approach has been a factor in the character's longevity, and we have Alan Moore (as well as Miller) to thank for that.

Sunday, 16 June 2013

Spiderman Reign


Batman: The Dark Knight Returns was a gritty, dystopian tale of Batman’s return to the streets after a decade of retirement. Spiderman Reign is exactly the same thing. But with Spiderman. And not quite as good.

The trouble Spiderman Reign has is that it is so obviously designed to be Marvel’s answer to Dark Knight. Deliberately setting out to emulate such a successful book is always going to be a dangerous thing to do because anything you get wrong is going to be amplified by the original’s success.

I’m not a big fan of DKR but I can see where its appeal lies. I can also appreciate that it was an interesting idea borne of its time. It was in part a response to the world Frank Miller found himself in in the eighties. It’s grim and dark because Miller was in a world that was grim and dark and, crucially, its success came in part because that simply wasn’t what comics did at the time.

Spiderman Reign was produced in 2006. As far as comics are concerned that places it firmly into the era of retreads, cash-ins, and set-ups for movies. That’s a far cry from the world of originality Miller was writing in.

The story sees Peter Parker return to the streets of New York City as Spidey after a period of inactivity that’s seen him wind up as a florist. How and why he gave up the photography and journalism career he’d juggled with his night job as Spiderman is never adequately addressed and is the first sign that the entire premise hasn’t really been thought through.

In NYC masked criminals are a thing of the past, the town now being under the protection of the powerful, and inevitably corrupt, Reign enforcement team. They answer to an equally corrupt mayor. Parker bumps into a teen that’s found himself on the receiving end of the overzealous law enforcers and gets beaten up by the cops. It’s this trivial occurrence that ultimately prompts him to don the mask again.

From there it’s the standard sequences of Spidey returning to the rooftops and getting one over on the bad guys in a series of Feel Good Moments™. This leads to the mayor unleashing Mysterio, Electro, Kraven, Sandman, Hydro-Man and Scorpion, collectively billed as the Sinner Six, from jail so that they can target New York’s premiere masked vigilante. Cameos are also made by J Jonah Jameson (who should really be dead by this point considering his age) and, for no particular reason, obscure enemy Hypno Hustler.

Despite the uninspired and vaguely confusing plot that dominates proceedings there are some nice ideas dotted throughout Reign’s slender four issue run. Doctor Octopus is shown to be a corpse slumped in the centre of his still functioning metal arms, stalking the city on the dead of night. That provides some nice visuals. There’s a climactic battle with Venom that’s well drawn. In fact the artwork of Kaare Andrews (who also wrote the script) and Jose Villarrubia is far better than the story deserves. It’s very evocative in places. It’s just a pity it doesn’t have anything substantial to work with.

Spiderman Reign is far from a must read. Pick it up and flick through it if you see it. If you like the art you’ll probably enjoy it as a(n expensive) diversion. Equally if you’re nuts about Spiderman then you’ll probably find it enjoyable enough. For anyone who doesn’t fall into either camp it’s probably best to save your money and buy something else instead.

Sunday, 12 May 2013

Batman: The Dark Knight Returns


I’ve tried to like Batman: The Dark Knight Returns. But I can’t. There’s something about it that stops me from doing so. It could be that it’s grim near-future setting had become played out by the time I came to read it. Which is a little unfair because when DKR was written the theme wasn’t as overplayed as it is now. It’s one of the titles that helped to make it popular.

Another problem could be the artwork. Frank Miller (who wrote the script and drew the book) is a talented artist but the panels here are too cramped and tightly packed. At times it’s hard to decipher what’s supposed to be going on and in what order you’re supposed to track the panels across the page. While that does add (deliberately I would hope) to the book’s sense of claustrophobia it makes enjoyment difficult to come by.

It’s that sense of claustrophobia that the book is often praised for. This near-future setting is a dystopia in which superheroics have been outlawed, replaced on the streets by brutal regiments of riot gear-swaddled police. The last cape standing is, predictably, Superman. He now works for the government (or “the man”, if you prefer) while a bitter (and aged) Bruce ‘Batman’ Wayne has retired.

Bruce’s decision to return to fighting the good fight is the story of Dark Knight Returns. You probably could have guessed that from the title. As the tale begins The Batman hasn’t been seen in Gotham City for a decade, crime levels are rising and Wayne is finding inaction increasingly difficult. Deciding to ignore the injury that caused him to retire in the first place he returns to the streets as ‘The Caped Crusader’ and quickly finds himself in a conflict with Harvey ‘Two-Face’ Dent.

Surprisingly few DC regulars crop up during the lengthy story. Superman and Green Arrow are the only heroes besides Batman with a presence, the latter feeling an odd choice because, nowadays at least, he’s a pretty low profile player. Joker appears as a patient-slash-prisoner at Arkham Asylum, and Catwoman crops up as the owner of an escort business. It’s that sort of a book.

That minimalistic approach is actually one of the book’s best attributes. Were it written today it would likely be a summer crossover event designed to find a place for even the most minor of characters. That Miller was given the freedom to use as many or as few characters as he deemed necessary is pleasing. It also ensures the book has enough time to develop what characters it does use, allowing us insight into what they’re feeling and why they’re doing what they’re doing. There’s little of that in the crossover approach.

Miller is at his best when creating dystopic nightmares. That’s what he’s given us with The Dark Knight Returns. It’s a world without hope and at least one of the points of the story appears to be that the world will always need Batman, which I think readers are supposed to take as the standard “fight for what you believe in” jazz.

It’s no wonder it was cited as a big inspiration the Nolan Bat trilogy: all three films, though particularly the final entry, owe a large debt to the depressing world Miller gives us here.

And yet I still can’t enjoy it, because of that artwork and Miller’s refusal to enliven the pace. The book drags for much of its page count. When it does get going it’s an enjoyable read and one of the best interpretations of Batman there’s ever been. Sadly those points don’t come frequently enough and there isn’t enough else in the book to help carry things when the plot lags.